All That Glitters: A Guide to Chicago’s Finest Jewelry Stores


Certain pieces of jewelry have the power to transform your entire mood. Something about the way the gems glow against your skin or the way your diamond ring catches the morning light; it’s enough to convince you to dress up and take on the day. These are the jewels you wear with an easy confidence, the ones you reach for again and again. 

And luckily, Chicago’s jewelry stores are more than enough to satisfy that craving for all that glitters. Look no further than these six showrooms for heirloom-quality selections and timeless designs. 

New York Jewelers

11 N Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60602

Located in the heart of downtown Chicago, New York Jewelers has been locally owned since 1890. It offers a particularly impressive selection of vintage-style pieces including pearl starburst pins, diamond halo vintage rings, golden topaz earrings, antique emerald, and diamond bracelets. New York Jewelers also caters to those interested in acquiring pre-owned pieces, offering watches from iconic brands such as Cartier, Omega, Patek Phillippe, and Rolex. 

Takohl Fine Jewelry

110 N Peoria St #101, Chicago, IL 60607

Takhol’s mission to inspire and connect people is just one of the reasons why it’s a favorite among Chicagoans. Visionary artist and founder Tammy Kohl pairs her expertise in gems and diamonds with her passion for sculpture to showcase pieces in styles ranging from antique to modern and everything in between. Kohl empowers her clients to participate in the design process, creating jewels that emulate their personal milestones and celebrations. The store’s signature Takhol Treasure Rings feature hidden latches that open like lockets, allowing clients to include meaningful engravings within their jewelry. 

Helene Lucille

1 E Delaware Pl, Chicago, IL 60611

With 24 years of expertise, Helene Lucille offers impeccable pieces that are sure to dazzle. Lucille describes jewelry as a wearable art form and enjoys working closely with clients to design unique statement pieces. Those seeking something sentimentality can even opt to rework their old or rarely worn jewelry to better suit their current style and preferences. 

La Kaiser Jewelry

5 S Wabash Ave Suite 300, Chicago, IL 60603

For those looking ahead to Valentine’s Day, La Kaiser offers a curated selection of their bestselling pieces like mini heart lockets, opal and diamond doublet studs, teal sapphire and diamond fleurette rings, mother of pearl pendants, and more. Founder Cindy Kaiser draws on her Swiss and Zimbabwean roots, as well as her international travels, to ideate simplistic yet elegantly designed jewelry pieces. 

Marshall Pierce 

​​960 N Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL 60611

With its rich history, Marshall Pierce serves as a testament to the extraordinary impact a family-owned and operated business can have. The company’s eponymous collection features brilliant, beautifully-cut jewels that are perfect for any occasion. When browsing their showroom, you can also take a look at their newest collection from Paul Morelli Jewelry. All Morelli designs are rendered from the original hand-made casts at the Morelli atelier and meticulously inspected for details. 

Fey & Co

Lincoln Park. 758 W. North Ave., Chicago, IL 60610

When you purchase jewelry from Fey & Co, you can feel proud about supporting their environmentally-conscious and community-oriented mission. Their Forevermark Diamonds are responsibly sourced, upholding their commitment to the highest standard of ethics and craftsmanship. All jewelry has a story—at least, that’s how Fey & Co sees it. And there’s no better way to tell your story than investing in a piece from a local Chicago studio.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x

Discover more from Concierge Preferred

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading